The Cost Effectiveness of Alpha SPF Roofs: Casa View Elementary School Roofing Case Study

Dean Kashiwagi, Charles J. Zulanas IV, Dhaval Gajjar

Abstract


The performance of the Alpha Sprayed Polyurethane Foam (SPF) roofing system is perceived as not an economical option when compared to a 20-year modified roofing system. The Dallas Independent School District (DISD) is replacing the existing Alpha SPF roof systems with new roof systems rather than recoating the existing systems at a cost that is 100% more than the recoating costs. The DISD is in a heavy hail area, and the proven hail resistance of the Alpha SPF roof system is an additional benefit for DISD who is self-insured. The Casa View Elementary School roof system was installed with a Neogard Permathane roof system in 1987. This roof was hail tested with ten drops from 17 feet 9 inches of 1-3/4-inch steel ball (9 out of 10 passed) and three drops from 17 feet 9 inches with a 3-inch diameter steel ball (1 out of 3 passed). The analysis of the passing and failing core samples show that the thickness of the top and base Alpha SPF coating is one of the major differences in a roof passing or failing the FM-SH hail test. The current potential cost savings of purchasing a 61,000 square feet Alpha SPF roof versus modified bitumen roof is approximately $610,000 for DISD. The past hail tests on Alpha SPF roof systems show high customer satisfaction (9.8 out of 10) and an over 40-year service life after a $6.00/SF recoat.


References


Alumbaugh, R. L., & Humm, E. F. (1984). Experimental Polyurethane Foam Roof Systems. Journal of Cellular Plastics, 257-273.

Coffelt, D. P., & Hendrickson, C. T. (2010). Life-cycle costs of commercial roof systems. Journal of Architectural Engineering, 16(1), 29-36.

Gajjar, D. R., Kashiwagi, D. T., & Kashiwagi, J. (2012). Manufacturer's New Approach To Risk. RICS COBRA 2012, 1859-1868.

Improvenet. (2014, June 17). How Much Does Foam Roofing Cost? Retrieved July 26, 2016, from http://www.improvenet.com/r/costs-and-prices/foam-roofing.

Kashiwagi, D., Gajjar, D., Kashiwagi, J., & Sullivan, K. (2016). Hail Study on a 15 Year Old Sprayed Polyurethane Foam Roofing System. Journal for the Advancement of Performance Information & Value, 8(1).

Kashiwagi, D., Gajjar, D., Kashiwagi, J., & Sullivan, K. (2015). The Replacement of Warranties with Logic and Common Sense. Journal for the Advancement of Performance Information & Value, 7(1).

Kashiwagi, D. T. and Tisthammer, T. (2002) Information Based Delivery System for Sprayed Polyurethane Foam on Roofing, Journal of Thermal Envelope & Building Science, (26), 33-52.

Kashiwagi, D., & Pandey, M. (1996). Oversize Hail Resistance Test of Elastomeric Coated Sprayed-In-Place Polyurethane Foam (SPF) Roof Systems. Performance Based Studies Research Group, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ. 1-155.

Koontz, Jim and Crenshaw, Vickie (2001). SIMULATED HAIL DAMAGE AND IMPACT RESISTANCE TEST PROCEDURE. Article based on Presentation at Roofing Industry Committee on Weather Issues (RICOWI) meeting Oct. 27, 2000, in Dallas, Texas. Shttp://www.rci-online.org/interface/2001-05-crenshaw-koontz.pdf.

Knowles, M. (2005, September 29). Specifying SPF Roofing Systems. Retrieved April 17, 2013, from http://www.buildings.com/article-details/articleid/2753/title/specifying%20spf%20roofing%20systems.aspx.

Maintenance Solutions. (2015). Built-up Roofing and Modified Bitumen Systems: A Smart Roofing Decision. Retrieved July 26, 2016, from http://www.asphaltroofing.org/press-room/press-releases/built-roofing-and-modified-bitumen-systems-smart-roofing-decision.

PBSRG. (2016). Performance Based Studies Research Group Internal Research Documentation, Arizona State University, Unpublished Raw Data.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.